Journal of Controversial Ideas

(ISSN: 2694-5991) Open Access Journal
Rss Feed:
Controversial Ideas 2021, 1(1), 9; doi: 10.35995/jci01010009

Deflating Byrne’s “Are Women Adult Human Females?”

Received: 8 Feb 2021 / Revised: 5 Mar 2021 / Accepted: 6 Mar 2021 / Published: 25 Apr 2021
View Full-text Download PDF (172kb)


The primary aim of this paper is to show that Alex Byrne’s arguments in “Are Women Adult Human Females?” provide no reason to doubt the truth of the proposition that trans women are women. Byrne’s conclusion is that women are adult human females. However, it is safe to say that much of the interest in his article is driven by the assumption that it is a short step from that conclusion to the further conclusion that trans women are not women. If Byrne is understood to be defending that further conclusion, however, then some of his arguments are dialectically ineffective. The others commit an evidential fallacy or rest on a false premise.
Keywords: gender; sex; trans; Alex Byrne
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. (CC BY 4.0).
Heartsilver, M. Deflating Byrne’s “Are Women Adult Human Females?”. Controversial_Ideas 2021, 1, 9.
Heartsilver M. Deflating Byrne’s “Are Women Adult Human Females?”. Journal of Controversial Ideas. 2021; 1(1):9.
Heartsilver, Maggie. 2021. "Deflating Byrne’s “Are Women Adult Human Females?”." Controversial_Ideas 1, no. 1: 9.
Not implemented